Protect Glade Watershed
  • History
  • Watersheds
    • BC WATERSHEDS
    • Glade Community Water & Threat
    • Glade Creek Watershed
    • Watershed Reserves
  • Society Activities
    • Overview: Our Timeline
    • Section 29 & Interior Health Authority
    • Legal Attempts
    • Forest Practices Board Complaint
    • Eco-System Based Community Forest >
      • Restoration & Wildcrafting in the Forest
  • Forests & Wildlife
    • Importance of Forests
    • Almost no Protection for Water, Old Growth, Wildlife....
    • Grizzly habitat threatened
    • CARIBOU Beyond 'Threatened'
    • OLD GROWTH being Logged
  • Take ACTION!
    • How You can Help
    • Contact Us
    • PLEASE Donate!
  • Impacts & climate change
    • Community Questionnaire
    • Impacts from Logging & Road Building
    • Wildfire, Carbon & Beetles
    • Climate Change: the Kootenays and Glade
  • Timber Industry
    • Professional Reliance
    • Forestry Stats (CoFI)
    • Exporting Logs & Labour
  • Local Timber Industry
    • Interior Lumber Manufacturer's Association
    • Sustainable, Renewable resource?
    • Failing Forest Stewardship plans & Forest Practices Board
  • Proposed Logging in Glade
    • Who is Responsible?
    • Proposed Logging (Kalesnikoff - KLC)
    • KLC Updates
    • Proposed LOGGING (ATCO)
  • Links, News, Newsletter
    • Latest Press Release
    • Newsletter
    • In the NEWS
    • Publications & Links
  • Upcoming Events
    • Markets, etc...
    • Citizen's Climate Lobby Canada
Looking for something on our website?  See the Search feature at the bottom of every page.


Self Regulation aka Professional Reliance

Over the years, corporate spin-doctors have found devious new ways to shed rules
and government oversight, but professional reliance was a stroke of pure genius.

Many were lulled into thinking that handing the management and oversight of our public lands and interest to a coterie of smiling, reliable professionals, with their reputations and professional associations hovering above to keep them in line, was a grand solution.
 
FOCUS
magazine, Sept 2017: New Government will Review "Professional Reliance" 

Picture
Still photo from Sonora Island 'Professional Reliance' video. https://vimeo.com/252243072/d76f33baf0
The BC government wanted to hear from the public (Jan2018) on the management model of Professional Reliance. There was a short survey to complete and the public could also make a more detailed submission. The submissions have been posted online for the public to read, and there are approximately 106 submissions posted so far.
Click here to read the submissions: engage.gov.bc.ca/professionalreliance/read-stakeholder-submissions/
There are many well researched articles, please have a scroll through them.  
A few of the submissions:
BC Tap Water Alliance
Herb Hammond (Forest Ecologist)
L
aird Creek, Balfour
BC Coalition for Forestry Reform
T.Pearse
This is the submission from the Glade Watershed Protection Society:
final_noaddress.submission_provincial_review_of_professional_reliancegwps.pdf
File Size: 1038 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

This is an excellent video from the folks from the Sonora Island community. They say: "This video submission is based on the experience of the Sonora Island community’s interactions with TimberWest Forest Corporation in the southern Great Bear Rainforest over the last 5 years." (Three photos below are still shots from their video). 
https://vimeo.com/252243072/d76f33baf0
Picture
Picture
Picture

'Self-Regulation' becomes 'Professional Reliance'
At one time the industry answered to the Ministry, who provided checks and balances of a sort. In 2004, the industry became self regulated. Which means the logging company is regulating itself, keeping an eye on themselves and making sure they do everything by the book. 'Self regulation' has been renamed 'Professional Reliance'. Now they must rely on professionals. These professionals are contracted by the logging companies and have stated that they are unbiased.
In the end, who decides to do the logging can easily consist of only one professional hired by the lumber company, and the licensee's Foresters (RPF). 
A. Nikiforuk in  "Another Wild West Show? BC’s Regulatory Experiment with Professional Reliance" (The Tyee Dec2017) states:
First introduced nearly a decade ago, the practice now dominates 27 different regulatory regimes in the province.
The B.C. government defines the term as “the practice of accepting and relying upon the decisions and advice of professionals who accept responsibility and can be held accountable for the decisions they make and the advice they give.”
To support PR, as it sometimes called, the B.C. government streamlined regulations, reduced the size of the public service, and gave industry proponents a greater role in monitoring their compliance with environmental rules.
The government said the scheme would save money and result in better governance.  
But a growing body of critics, including B.C.’s Auditor General, the B.C. Ombudsperson, and the University of Victoria’s Environmental Law Centre say that’s not what is happening in practice.
They say professional reliance has given industry too much control over public lands without addressing conflicts of interest. They also say it amounts to deregulation and less government oversight.
In particular they are concerned about conflicts of interest. Given that most engineers or foresters are employed or retained by an industrial proponent, an inherent potential for conflict arises between duties to the client and the public interest in environmental protection.  (https://thetyee.ca/News/2017/02/21/BC-Professional-Rethetyee.ca/News/2017/02/21/BC-Professional-Reliance-Experiment/)
Losing Public Confidence:
From an article "Agencies blow whistle on forestry self-policing" Business Vancouver, Sept 2014
Problems in B.C’s forest regulatory system are raising flags....prompting some to say the province is at risk of losing public confidence in resource development.... the B.C. auditor general, the B.C. ombudsperson  and the Forest Practices Board have all written reports within the last two years on the failures associated with the practice of relying on professionals employed by resource companies to manage the province’s forests...the government has abandoned its role as a knowledgeable owner and steward of the land base when it introduced regulatory changes in 2004.
(Auditor General report, Ombudsperson Report, FPB Report)
Professional Assessments:
Are the recommendations followed?

It was an 'unknown' as to how the professional consultants (employed by the company) and the logging companies relate to one another.
In the Feb 2016 Glade public meeting, the Kalesnikoff representative stated that he saw the hydrogeomorphic recommendations as 'binding'. He added if he "went outside the hydrogeomorphic report and I was brought before my peers, I would be in trouble." (Castlegar News article Feb 25, 2016).
However, in a previous community meeting (Sept 2015) with ATCO and Kalesnikoff, the Terrain Specialist stated that sometimes the logging companies "don't even follow their own professionals' recommendations".
This is echoed by a Forest Practices Board statement that "license holders are under no obligation to accept the advice of these resource professionals".
(FPB Report: Are They Meeting Expectations?)

Search, Subscribe, and Contact Us! TAKE ACTION!
Edited April 2021

EMAIL us!

Search our website
Picture
The value that the forest adds to the health and welfare of all life is paramount and how we care for the elements of nature that provide us with these benefits should be foremost in our actions. This value is as important as or, or even more important than, economic gain, for without the forest ecosystems we cannot flourish. Water is the priority – our forests that produce that water is our priority. Water is life and without clean water, nothing can live.       
                                                                      Glade Watershed Protection Society,
Glade, Castlegar, West Kootenays, British Columbia, Canada
  • History
  • Watersheds
    • BC WATERSHEDS
    • Glade Community Water & Threat
    • Glade Creek Watershed
    • Watershed Reserves
  • Society Activities
    • Overview: Our Timeline
    • Section 29 & Interior Health Authority
    • Legal Attempts
    • Forest Practices Board Complaint
    • Eco-System Based Community Forest >
      • Restoration & Wildcrafting in the Forest
  • Forests & Wildlife
    • Importance of Forests
    • Almost no Protection for Water, Old Growth, Wildlife....
    • Grizzly habitat threatened
    • CARIBOU Beyond 'Threatened'
    • OLD GROWTH being Logged
  • Take ACTION!
    • How You can Help
    • Contact Us
    • PLEASE Donate!
  • Impacts & climate change
    • Community Questionnaire
    • Impacts from Logging & Road Building
    • Wildfire, Carbon & Beetles
    • Climate Change: the Kootenays and Glade
  • Timber Industry
    • Professional Reliance
    • Forestry Stats (CoFI)
    • Exporting Logs & Labour
  • Local Timber Industry
    • Interior Lumber Manufacturer's Association
    • Sustainable, Renewable resource?
    • Failing Forest Stewardship plans & Forest Practices Board
  • Proposed Logging in Glade
    • Who is Responsible?
    • Proposed Logging (Kalesnikoff - KLC)
    • KLC Updates
    • Proposed LOGGING (ATCO)
  • Links, News, Newsletter
    • Latest Press Release
    • Newsletter
    • In the NEWS
    • Publications & Links
  • Upcoming Events
    • Markets, etc...
    • Citizen's Climate Lobby Canada